Periodically I come across a news article on Maths in schools that sets me off on a grumpy rant. I’ll try to reign it in here, but this recent article on the BBC website (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-179136490 ) was pretty special. The opening paragraph read “Maths lessons are seen as difficult, irrelevant and boring by about a third of teenagers, a survey suggests” and went on to (with little evident statistical strength) merrily slosh about the usual British stereotypes about our subject.
I wonder if the author of this lazy article ever considered opening with “Maths lessons are seen as challenging, useful & rewarding by about two thirds of teenagers” instead.
There was the usual guff about the inherent lack of usefulness of Maths (“Somehow I doubt I’ll use trigonometry anytime in the future“), “Real Life” Mathematics (as opposed to what?), a few casual (ironic?) percentages to imply that their arguments should be taken seriously and many other facepalming moments.
All the article does is show how the media perpetuate these myths- the primary cause of this phenomenon.
I’d contend that the article’s headline should have run along the lines of:
“Maths education now misperceived in record number of ways”.
Rant over.
Anyway it did allow me to reflect on how our pupils at King’s perceive Maths. We do at times encounter many of these weird British stereotypes but increasingly we are seeing these perceptions (dull, intellectual, non-applicable, useful-but-I-don’t-know-why, Maths=Numeracy etc) shunned by many of our students across the yeargroups.
As evidence, I’d happily offer our outgoing Upper Sixth Form, whose final lessons before study leave are tolling around the department before their departure next week.
We’ve had 40 pupils in Upper Sixth study A2 Mathematics this academic year with another 8 completing some form of Further Maths and they’ve embraced the subject both within and beyond their lessons. Many attended our visits to Liverpool, where a throwaway line about “Maths Parties” by Mathematical Stand-up Matt Parker was brought to life by our pupils (I tend not to ask what goes on in them just to be on the safe side). We now have students with offers from some of the strongest Mathematics university courses in the country although some of those pupils whose academic passions have led them to study other subjects have spoken with genuine melancholy of the imminent and hitherto unexplored prospect of life without learning any new Maths!
These pupils embraced and drove our series of lectures on off syllabus Mathematics and the two Further Maths groups led one terrific lecture session themselves. They even came up with names for their groups- one is named “Da Mandelbrot Set” (because “i is in da Mandelbrot set”- for non-specialists that’s a Complex number joke and trust me, it’s a belter) and the other the “Maths Pack”- which, when they learned that I was going to reveal this in a blog, offered mildly embarrassed apologies. Their love of learning Maths has been clear to see but across the entire Upper Sixth year and in all sets we have seen hard work coupled with a genuine curiosity for and enjoyment of the study of Mathematics.
Of greatest significance is that this love of learning is not borne of wanting access to algorithms for “the real world” (although in actuality they have learned a great deal which can be transferred to a wide variety of future careers), but a desire to broaden their intellectual frontiers.
As a department we wish them every deserved success in their varied futures. Who knows- some of them might even use Trigonometry at some point.
NAS